The novel’s emotional crescendo comes at Robin and Mercy’s Fiftieth-anniversary social gathering. (Twenty years after she moved out, they nonetheless haven’t instructed the youngsters.) Watching house motion pictures along with his disconnected, taciturn brood, Robin displays: “Had there been some type of restrict, in these days, on how lengthy a scene might final? Each was so transient. … Pouf! After which goodbye. Goodbye to all of it. … It had flown by means too quick, he thought because the display went clean. And he didn’t imply solely the film.”
“French Braid” is a novel about what’s remembered, what we’re left with when all the alternatives have been made, the kids raised, the desires realized or deserted. It’s a transferring meditation on the passage of time.
The novel ends on a poignant word, as David, now retired, finds himself unexpectedly awash in household intimacy when his son strikes in with him through the pandemic. He’s startled to acknowledge Garrett household traits in his 5-year-old grandson. “David’s father had raised his shoulders like that every time he was intent on some job — a person Benny had by no means laid eyes on.” It leads him to recall the French braids his daughter wore as a baby: “When she undid them, her hair would nonetheless be in ripples.”
David tells his spouse: “That’s how households work, too. You suppose you’re freed from them, however you’re by no means actually free; the ripples are crimped in perpetually.”
The second is classic Tyler: the epiphany that may shock nobody, a intelligent rephrasing of standard knowledge that merely affirms what we already imagine. It’s why some (principally male) critics have, through the years, dismissed her work as sentimental — the defining attribute of the style often called “girls’s fiction.” It’s a publishing euphemism that carries greater than a whiff of misogyny, implying that fiction written by and about girls is by definition one thing lower than literature — heartwarming somewhat than cerebral, reassuring somewhat than difficult. To make sure, over her lengthy profession Tyler has often fallen into these traps. (See “A Patchwork Planet.”) However “French Braid” is the alternative of reassuring. The novel is imbued with an old-school feminism of a sort at present retro. It appears squarely on the penalties of stifled feminine ambition — to the girl herself, and to these in her orbit.
For all its appeal, “French Braid” is a quietly subversive novel, tacklinging elementary assumptions about womanhood, motherhood and feminine growing old. Opposite to the message of a thousand self-help books, Mercy’s efforts to start a profession at midlife are fruitless. She advertises her providers in neighborhood grocery shops, on laundromat bulletin boards: “Let a Skilled Artist Paint Your Home’s Portrait.” After many years as a housewife, home life is her solely topic.
In mourning the misplaced prospects of Mercy’s life, Tyler takes purpose at a sentimental trope deeply embedded in American tradition. The feminist motion however, standard tradition (to not point out “girls’s fiction”) nonetheless clings to the notion of motherhood as the final word emotional success, the nice and crowning satisfaction of a lady’s life. For Mercy Garrett, that merely isn’t the case.